We recently had a learning experience in our home. While staying at Grandma and Grandpas one night, my 9yr old happened to see part of a detective TV show that really disturbed her. She had bad dreams for a few nights in a row. We talked a lot about it. I had her describe to me what she has seen. And any adult of even teenager, would not have even blinked at it (a little past feeling I suppose). But this one scene showed something that had never ever entered into her brain before and it greatly disturbed her. We had a talk about how terrible things happen in this world. I told her I wished that I could say that things like that never happened, but they do and it is awful. But just because things like that happen in the world, doesn't mean that we should watch it(a wake up call for me). We then had a discussion about what she could do when she started thinking about what she saw. A few days later she came to me and told me she was still having a hard time. I told her that Satan had found an in, and he was using it to get to her. I told her that she need to not let Satan win. I then had her write out her favorite scripture(Alma 30:44 "The scriptures are laid before thee, yea, and all things denote there is a God...") on a index card and carry it with her. Then she could read it when ever she started thinking about the show. Eventually she'd have it memorized and then she could used it when ever she had bad thoughts. I was grateful to have listened to that prompting, she hasn't had any problems since(at least not that she has told me).
A week or so after this happened, my sweetpea brought home a book from school that we had ordered through Scholasitc books. It looked like it would be a fun book for us to read together at night. When she came home with it, she gave it to me and said "Mom, do you think we can hold off reading this for awhile? I'm just afraid to read it because of the show I watched." I told her that that would be fine, we would read something different, and in the mean time I would read the first couple of chapters to see what the book was like. As I started to read it, I realised that it wasn't at all what we thought it was going to be. That the subject matter was to "old" for my kids, and that it likely wasn't a book that I would want them to read even when they were older. I asked her the next day if she had started reading it and if that was why she didn't want to read it. She told me that she hadn't because she was too scared. I told her that I was proud of her, because she had listened to the spirit warn her that that wasn't a book that she needed to read. We donated that book to the library.
The main thing that I learned from these incidences is that I need to be more careful about what I read and watch. Which brings me to the next part of my post...
Everyone, and I mean EVERYONE seems to be raving about how amazing the Hunger Games books and movie are. The premise of the books disturbs me. Today I read a little debate on a friends Facebook status about whether or not to let her kids watch the movie. I was astounded by what seemed to me, simple justification, of the commenters as to why they thought these were good books and movie.
One commenter wrote "I must be made of steel or something - I thought it was awesome, and again, I was that inappropriate MOM and took [my daughter] to it too. Somehow, watching it together we could talk about it and it was OK."
"I must be made of steel. " I believe that is what Nephi meant when he rebuked his brothers " But ye were past feeling, that ye could not feel his words;"(1Nephi 17:45). This statement does nothing to convince me that these books are worth reading. It does the absolute opposite and warns me that this is something I should probably stay away from.
Another said "See and while the movie was probably made for entertainment, I believe Suzanne Collins wrote the books with a much deeper message in mind. I also think we can have great discussions with our (older) kids about this. I mean, look at our obsession with reality TV- picking people at random for our amusement. Sure, killing is the extreme- but it's also showing corruption in the Government and the track we would take if that were to ever happen. And I also agree, that there is tons of literature out there made to shock (The Lottery, Lord of the Flies) I think it's a good thing if it makes us think."
So we are already watching crazy amounts of reality TV, let's take it to the extreme and throw in some violence and make it into a book. Now that sounds amusing. WHAT? I do agree that thinking is a good thing, but do I need to read fictional violence to encourage me to think? There is plenty of violence and war happening in this world that I can take the time to learn about that will get me to think. Is it really necessary to add it to our entertainment to get us to think?
And another "I feel that the books really portrayed a strong, important and sobering message. The thing is, there are children who actually live like this (well, not with the glamour and glitz) in a state of war, today. That's something I think we should be aware of and why I don't see the message as being so far out there. It's a reality for many in this world and we are fortunate that it isn't for us. But it COULD be, one day."
I can be aware of children who live in war torn areas. But I don't see a need to be "entertained" by it through fictional movies and books. If you want to read about children who actually live like this, try reading "A long way gone; memoirs of a boy soldier" by Ishmael Beah. This book is heartbreaking. It is not an easy read. It is graphic, it is very real. You will cry, the reality that is portrayed in this book is paralyzing. I'm sure there are other non-fiction books out there similar to this, this just happens to be one that I have read recently.
Another commenter mentioned "The Authors purpose in writing them was to teach kids about war and peace. I found them disturbing but because of the reality I saw in them. To teach kids about war is a powerful and vital thing. The horrors and realities of it and that sometimes you have to fight for peace which can be incredibly horrific. We are taking our kids to Vimy, France as well as Flanders Field in Belgium to help teach them about war. If we don't remember we will forget. Hopefully we raise our children to be strong enough to fight for what they believe is right which is taught through the hunger games trilogy."
That's just it, there are other ways to teach our children about war and peace and it is important. But there are more meaningful ways to do it. Like discussing the wars that have shaped our country. Or about the wars that are shaping the world today. And yes, I want to raise our children to be strong enough to fight for what is right. But I do not feel that I need a fictional novel(or movie) laced with violence, to aid me in this quest.
And one with a statement I like least of all. "The message of the books have nothing to do, actually with killing, in and of itself. They were written to show how war affects children. At the end of the the trilogy, though things are getting on an even track, no one comes away unscathed. They aren't back to 'business as usual'. It's not a happily ever after, fairy tale ending where everyone gets what they want and the bad guys are all eradicated.
We really live in a society that has been shielded from events similar to stuff like this, and in pondering some of these concepts, we can come to a better understanding of the importance of preserving our freedoms, of teaching our children and those around us about the importance of humanity, compassion and sanctity of life. It's not that far off that society can become depraved and destructive. The events that have, are and will happen the world around are reality.
It's true, they aren't for everyone.
But they are certainly an education. Not an easy one, but one that helps us see the need to stay close to the Lord."
We are only shielded from similar events because we choose to be. If we wanted to learn about what is really going on in this world we can. Maybe not on the regular evening news, but seriously folks, can we not find just about anything on the great big world wide web these days? And honestly this isn't a new idea. Killing for pleasure and the entertainment of a crowd that has happened in many civilizations. Lets look at the ancient Gladiators that were thrown in an arena to fight their opponents to the death. Or how about the ancient Mayan soccer like games where teams literally played to the death. Or how about not so far in the past, Nazi Germany who killed millions of Jews, just because. Or any other genocides that have happened in the not so distant past.
And my least favorite statement, "But they are certainly an education. Not an easy one, but one that helps us see the need to stay close to the Lord." Since when do I need a fictional book to help me stay close to the Lord? Is there not enough war and bloodshed in the Book of Mormon to help us see the need to stay close to the Lord? Not only that, it then teaches us how to stay close to the Lord?
I don't doubt these books are well written. I am sure they are "entertaining". I can even believe that in the right environment, one may even learn some important lessons from reading them. But they aren't for me and my house. I admit I know very little about them. But what I do know has done nothing to endear me to them, but rather to warn me that I don't need them in my life.
I know there may be a day when my children will be older and may be required to read these books or similar books in school. We will deal with that when that time comes. I remember in High School reading "The Great Gatsby" and being appalled by it's content. My hope is that we will have taught our children sufficiently that when they are required to read such things, they too will be appalled because they will recognize the Spirit telling them so.
Please tell me I'm not the only one?
*************************update*****************************
I have since discovered that I am NOT the only one. You may find other posts on this topic here and here.And one more post, that isn't directly about these books, but one that fits in quite nicely can be found here.

